Vitale’s of Allegan

Reviews

• Felicia B.

  star star star star star 3 June 2026

  So good! Better than it's been in years. Our group had wet burrito which received raved reviews. Agustino sub - really good and fresh, bread not soggy like the last few times we've ordered (6+ mths ago).
  Ham and Cheese and Meatball sub eaters all reported better than before as well. But the real winner.... Cannolis! Ooo my word. Yumm!
  
  We'll definitely be back!

• Isabelle B.

  star star star star_border star_border 31 May 2026

  Great food, expensive though. Our family enjoyed it but we can't afford a $60 pizza Friday each week. Will have to save this locale for special occasions.

• Erienne B.

  star star star star star_border 17 May 2026

  I just moved to Allegan last week and decided to order delivery from here while I unpacked boxes. The online ordering from the website is super efficient and easy to use. You can customize everything about your pizza, from extra sauce or cheese to which kind of crust you want. Pizza came hot and fresh and I ordered a 12 pc hot wings on the side. The wings were perfectly sauced and had a great smoky flavor to them. Definitely the best wings I've had from a pizza place in a long time!
  
  The online website says to expect 60 minutes for delivery, but my food came close to 90 minutes later even though my house is right down the road. Delivery driver was very friendly. I did see that they are looking to hire more drivers which could be the reason for my delay. I will definitely order again.

• Nikki M.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 13 May 2026

  We order takeout often, and tonight we came inside to pickup our order, while waiting we saw the lady who was working pick off a topping from a pizza she was putting in the oven and eat it.  My mom and I both looked at each other and said "did you just see that".  The lady did it again with a piece of bread as we were cashing out our order.  That is completely disgusting and putting people at risk for illness.  She never washed her hands.  I also don't think it's very hygienic that the workers who prepare food do not where gloves.

• Jen B.

  star star star star star 10 May 2026

  Friendly service, great pizza, I do not normally do reviews but when I read some of the negative reviews I had to make it a point to let people know what a great experience my family had.